Home > Recipes > Top 10 List: Chocolate and Peanut Butter Recipes
by Michelle
April 4, 2016
A roundup of 10 of my all-time favorite chocolate and peanut butter recipes!
I began compiling top 10 lists of different recipe categories here on Brown Eyed Baker after receiving a lot of questions about which were my favorite recipes since there were so many lurking in the archives. Totally understandable! I began putting them together a couple of years ago and have been updating them ever since. Once the last batch was updated, I received a ton of requests to put together a top 10 list of my favorite chocolate and peanut butter recipes.
Doh! How could I have forgotten that oh-so-important category?! I’ve finally compiled a list of my favorite recipes that marry two of my all-time loves – chocolate and peanut butter. Enjoy browsing, and don’t forget to share your favorites with me below!
1. Buckeyes
2. Buckeye Brownies
3. Chocolate Peanut Butter Torte
4. Chubby Hubby Truffles
5. Homemade Peanut Butter Cups
6. Homemade Snickers Bars
7. Peanut Butter Cup Bars
8. Peanut Butter Cup Crunch Brownie Bars
9. Peanut Butter Cup Icebox Cake
10. Peanut Butter Cup Overload Cake
What’s YOUR favorite chocolate and peanut butter recipe??!
« Previous PostFriday Things
Next Post »Pretzel Bark Candy
20 Comments on “Top 10 List: Chocolate and Peanut Butter Recipes”
-
Maytha Kilgore — Reply
One of our favorite peanut butter/ chocolate recipes is:
NO BAKE PEANUT BUTTER BARSCombine 1 1/4 cup graham cracker crumbs (chocolate Graham’s best), 1/4 cup sugar, 1/2 teas nutmeg, 1/2 teas cinnamon in a mixing bowl. Add 1/3 cup light corn syrup and 1/2 cup peanut butter and work until thoroughly combined. Press into greased 8″ square pan. Melt 1 cup chocolate chips and spread over mixture. Chill about an hour for chocolate to set. Cut into squares, makes about 16.
Until last week I had always used regular graham crackers, but had chocolate ones on hand – we liked these even better with the chocolate grahams.
-
Pop — Reply
I’ve made the Peanut Butter Overload Cake. It was great! Going to have to try the Buckeye Browines and the Icebox Cake.
-
wendy — Reply
The ice box cake looks amazing, never made one before, maybe i was waiting for this one…..
-
Momstarr — Reply
Are there any others? This list pretty much covers the best of the best of chocolate peanut butter creations. Whoever put those two together should be crowned king.
-
Martha in KS — Reply
Great timing! My precious niece’s first baby is due any day now & peanut butter & dark chocolate are her two favorite flavors. Now – which recipe to make for her?
-
Lauren Massarellla — Reply
WOW. First off, this combo is my everything. I literally just ate a piece of dark chocolate with peanut butter smeared on it. So, basically, this top ten list is like my dream come true. Cannot wait to make some of these soon! Thank you! xo
-
Barb — Reply
My favorite combo. They all look good. It took forever to get to the recipes waiting for all the goofy ads to load before it would let me get to your things.
-
Lynne — Reply
My favorite chocolate and peanut butter recipe is for O’Henry Bars.
http://www.food.com/recipe/oh-henry-bars-35579 -
Erin @ The Spiffy Cookie — Reply
My kind of roundup!
-
Mel — Reply
The buckeye brownies are the best! If you haven’t made them, go do it!
-
Linda — Reply
Buckeyes are my favorite thing on your list.
-
Rena — Reply
We love YOUR buckeye cookies!
but they didn’t make the list!-
Michelle — Reply
It was sooooo hard to narrow down to just 10!! Hard decisions ;-)
-
-
Michelle — Reply
Oh! My! I WILL be making that peanut butter torte within the next several weeks. Guaranteed! I even have that cookbook and have never noticed that recipe before . . . (I know – ‘you’ve got to be kidding’ . . .) And those buckeye brownies just may have found it to the top of my list for our Memorial Day camping weekend. Thanks for bringing both of those recipes to the forefront of what I’ve been missing :) My hips and waist thank you ;)
-
Michelle — Reply
That torte is amazing! I’ve made it so many times, I really need to update the post with new photos, the old ones are awful and don’t do it justice!
-
-
Sally — Reply
My favorite chocolate and peanut butter treat is no bake cookies. I must not be a real chocolate and peanut butter fan because none of these are screaming, or even whispering, “make me!”
-
Maytha Kilgore — Reply
Sally,
Check out the recipe I just sent for No Bake Fudge Nuggets. Our family loves them and they are super easy, always a plus.
-
-
Linda — Reply
That’s a great list, love that there’s 2 Ohio recipes on there! I would say a couple other
favorites of mine are good old no bakes ( with cocoa & oats) and I just LOVE plain brownies with peanut butter frosting! Boring, I know but sometimes the simplest things are the best! Recently I tried a dark chocolate brownie with peanut butter frosting and it was to die for. -
Vivian | stayaliveandcooking — Reply
Errm. I shouldn’t have looked. I’m so hungry now and craving peanutbutter and chocolate!
-
Sj Dc — Reply
Finally! Thank you!
